A manual licence lets you drive both kinds of car. An automatic licence lets you drive automatics only. That single restriction is the entire decision, and whether it matters depends on the jobs you might apply for, the cars you are likely to own, and whether you drive abroad. This guide argues both sides.
The difference between the two licences is one sentence long. A manual licence lets you drive manual and automatic cars. An automatic licence lets you drive automatics only. Every argument people have about this follows from that single line.
What has changed over the last decade is how much that restriction actually costs you. Less than it used to, because the cars being built now are overwhelmingly automatic. Not nothing, because the cars already on the road are not. Both halves of that are worth taking seriously before you book a first lesson.
What Your Licence Actually Says
Pass your test in a manual car and you hold full category B entitlement. Pass in an automatic and you hold category B with code 78 printed on the back of the card, which the DVLA defines as "restricted to vehicles with automatic transmission".
The DVLA's own summary of that entitlement is blunt: you can drive a category B vehicle, but only an automatic one.
There is no grace period for short journeys, no exemption for a car you own, and no version of it that depends on how confident you feel. It is a hard line, and the consequences of crossing it are set out in whether you can drive a manual on an automatic licence.
The Two Licences Side By Side
Stripped of the argument, the differences are short enough to fit in a table.
| Licence | Automatic | Manual |
|---|---|---|
| Category on the card | B with code 78 | B |
| Cars you may drive | Automatics only | Automatic and manual |
| Theory test | Identical | Identical |
| Practical test standard | 15 faults | 15 faults |
| Weekday practical test fee | £62 | £62 |
| Covers every electric car | Yes | Yes |
| Further test needed later | Possible, one practical | Never |
Fees from gov.uk and the pass standard from DVSA guidance on the practical test. Weekday fee shown; evenings, weekends and bank holidays are £75.
Every argument anyone has about this sits in the second row. The rest of it is identical, which is worth remembering the next time a school claims one route is quicker or gentler.
The Case For Automatic
The honest version of this case is about attention rather than difficulty. A beginner has a fixed budget of concentration, and in a manual a large slice of it goes on the clutch for the first several hours. In an automatic that slice goes somewhere else.
- Nothing to stall, so the junction that would have frightened you is just a junction
- Hill starts are the footbrake and nothing else, which matters if you test at Chingford
- One pedal controls speed, leaving more attention for mirrors, cyclists and signs
- Workable for people whose left leg, knee or hip makes a clutch painful or impossible
- It matches the car you are most likely to buy new, because every electric car is automatic
That last point is doing more work every year. The government has legislated a pathway to all new cars and vans being zero emission by 2035, with the end of purely petrol and diesel new car sales from 2030.
Electric cars have no clutch and no gearbox to speak of, so the direction of travel for new vehicles is entirely towards the transmission an automatic licence already covers. That is set out at more length in what an automatic licence means for electric cars.
There is a specifically local argument too. East London driving is stop-start: a lesson between Whitechapel and Bow covers a short distance and an enormous number of decisions, and a learner in a manual is working the clutch through most of them. On Mare Street or Barking Road, the automatic learner spends the hour deciding whether to hold back or go, which is the skill being examined.
The Objection Worth Taking Seriously
The argument you will hear most often against learning in an automatic is that a manual makes you a better driver. It deserves a real answer rather than a dismissal, because there is something true underneath it.
What is true is that clutch work makes you hold road speed and engine speed in your head at the same time. A learner who has spent forty hours matching a gear to a junction ends up with a running sense of how fast the car is travelling without looking at the speedometer.
An automatic learner has to build that awareness another way, which in practice means an instructor asking for a speed estimate at random moments until the guess stops being a guess. It is a real gap, and a good instructor closes it deliberately.
What is not true is the conclusion people draw from it. None of the DVSA's top ten reasons for failing the driving test involve gears.
The list opens with observation at junctions, mirrors before changing direction, moving off safely, positioning on a right turn and response to traffic lights.
Those are the things that decide whether a driver is safe on Barking Road on a Friday afternoon, and a gearbox contributes nothing to any of them. The fair version of the objection is that manual teaches one extra skill. It is not that manual teaches the important ones better.
The Case For Manual
This is the section most driving school websites skip. It should not be skipped, because for a real minority of learners manual is straightforwardly the right answer.
Jobs that specify it
Plenty of employers still write "full manual licence" into a job advert. Trades with older vans, delivery and courier work with mixed fleets, agency driving, some care and community transport roles, and anything involving towing a trailer or driving a vehicle someone else owns.
If your working life might plausibly involve driving somebody else's van, an automatic licence will occasionally shut a door for you. It is not common, but it is real, and it tends to happen at the least convenient moment.
Driving abroad and hiring cars
Hire fleets across much of Europe are still predominantly manual. An automatic is usually a paid upgrade, needs booking further ahead, and in smaller towns may not be available at all. If you expect to hire cars on holiday every year, a manual licence removes a recurring annoyance and a recurring cost.
The cheap end of the used market
If your budget for a first car is a few hundred pounds, you are shopping in the part of the market where manuals are most numerous and where an equivalent automatic tends to carry a premium. The gap narrows as prices rise and disappears entirely on newer cars, but at the bottom it is genuinely there.
Someone else's car in the household
The most common practical reason is the simplest. If the car sitting outside your house is a manual, and it is the car you would practise in and then borrow after you pass, learning in an automatic means you cannot use it. Private practice between lessons is one of the biggest variables in how long learning takes, and giving it up is a real cost.
What The Choice Does Not Change
Two things stay identical whichever you pick, and both get misrepresented constantly.
The first is the test. Same routes, same examiner, same fault sheet, same requirement of no more than 15 driving faults and no serious or dangerous fault. Nobody marks you more gently for having two pedals. The full picture, including what the pass-rate tables do and do not tell you, is in is it easier to pass in an automatic.
The second is the theory test. Same 50 multiple-choice questions in 57 minutes with a pass mark of 43, same 14 hazard perception clips, same £23. Nothing about the transmission you intend to learn in appears anywhere in it.
What It Costs Either Way
The fixed costs do not care which car you learn in. A first provisional licence is £34 online or £43 by post, the theory test is £23, and the practical is £62 on a weekday or £75 in the evening, at a weekend or on a bank holiday.
Lesson rates rarely decide anything either. Automatic hours here are £37, or £350 for a block of ten, and manual tuition across the trade is generally priced at a similar level. So the cost question is really a question about how many hours you need rather than what an hour costs, and hours are the part nobody can predict for you in advance.
The number quoted everywhere is around 47 hours of tuition plus roughly 20 hours of private practice. It is worth being straight about that figure: it circulates widely across the driving industry but it is not a statistic the DVSA publishes, so treat it as a rough middle rather than a target.
What does hold up in practice is that an automatic removes the clutch-control hours and leaves every hour of observation and planning untouched, and observation is where most of the syllabus lives.
Deciding In Five Minutes
Work down this list and stop at the first honest yes.
- Is there a manual car in your household you would practise in and later borrow? If yes, learn manual.
- Do you want driving work, or work where you might be handed somebody else's van? If yes, learn manual.
- Do you hire cars abroad most years and mind paying the automatic surcharge? If yes, lean manual.
- Is a clutch physically difficult for you? If yes, learn automatic and do not think about it again.
- Is your first car going to be bought new, on finance, or as a recent used car? If yes, automatic covers it.
- None of the above? Automatic, and get on with it.
That last line is not a dodge. For someone with no household car, no driving ambitions at work and no hire car booking, manual entitlement is an option they will never exercise, bought with hours of clutch practice.
If You Change Your Mind Later
Choosing automatic now is not permanent. You keep the automatic entitlement, take lessons in a manual with L plates, and sit a full practical test in a manual car. The DVSA confirms that you do not need to take a theory test to upgrade your licence, and that you can carry on driving automatics if you fail the manual test.
So the real question is not which licence you want forever but which you want first. Upgrading later costs a test fee and some lessons at a point when you already know how to drive, which is a cheaper skill to add than clutch control was when you knew nothing. The steps are in how to upgrade from an automatic licence to a manual one.
The Short Version
Manual buys you flexibility you may never use. Automatic buys you attention you will certainly use, on roads that demand a lot of it. If you can name a specific reason to want manual, take it seriously and go and learn manual. If you cannot, the restriction is theoretical and the attention is not.
Whichever way you go, the sequence afterwards is the same: provisional licence, theory test, lessons, practical, all of it laid out in the guide to learning to drive in East London. Prices for both course types are published on the prices page, and the automatic side of it is described in full on the automatic lessons page.
Automatic lessons in East London are £37 an hour, or £350 for a block of ten, with pick-up from home, work or a station included.
Book automatic lessonsQuestions people ask before they pick
Is an automatic licence a full driving licence?
Yes. It is category B with code 78, restricted to vehicles with automatic transmission. In every other respect it is a full licence: you can drive alone, carry passengers, use motorways and insure a car in the normal way.
Do employers really care whether my licence is automatic?
Most do not. The ones that do tend to be employers with older or mixed vehicle fleets, where you might be handed any van in the yard. If a job advert says full manual licence, it means it, and there is no way to argue round code 78.
Are automatic lessons more expensive than manual ones?
Not here. Both are £37 an hour, or £350 for a block of ten. Across the trade the two rates are usually close, so the honest comparison is about how many hours each takes rather than the price of one hour.
Can I take my test in an automatic and then buy a manual car?
Not legally, and not on your insurance. You would need to upgrade first by passing a practical test in a manual car. You do not have to sit the theory test again to do it.
Will an automatic licence limit me if I move abroad?
It depends where. Hire fleets in much of Europe are still mostly manual and automatics carry a surcharge, so frequent travellers feel the restriction more than anyone else. If that describes you, that is a genuine reason to learn manual.
If the automatic case is the one that fits you, the sensible next step is a single hour to see how you get on with it. Nothing beyond that lesson is committed.
Book automatic lessonsMore in Automatic driving
Published 1 September 2026. Prices and DVSA figures are checked when this page is revised. If anything here has changed, ring us and we will confirm it.